Video: Assessed and Filed: Why Vendor Risk Data Isn't the Same as Vendor Risk Visibility | Duration: 1694s | Summary: Assessed and Filed: Why Vendor Risk Data Isn't the Same as Vendor Risk Visibility | Chapters: Webinar Introduction (0s), Introduction and Setup (0s), Executive Security Questions (0s), Vendor Risk Assessment (0s), Third Party Risk (0s), Vendor Assessment Accountability (0s), Continuous Vendor Monitoring (0s), Vendor Assessment Strategies (0s), Data Assessment Practices (0s), Best Practices Framework (0s), Board Reporting Evolution (0s), Demonstrating GRC Value (0s), Final Takeaways (0s)
Transcript for "Assessed and Filed: Why Vendor Risk Data Isn't the Same as Vendor Risk Visibility": Grace? You can hear me from. this Welcome, everyone. This. is a MITRA Tech webinar. It's part of our series. It's all GURK to me. It's all governance, ethics, risk, and compliance to me. Thank you so much for being with us today. Today's topic is about why vendor risk data is not the same thing... A thing as vendor risk visibility. As always or at least very often, we have, an expert guest on the webinar today that is Reginald Youngblood. May I ask you to introduce yourself, please? Sure. And first, I would just like to say thank you for the opportunity to be on this with you, on a very important topic. I've got thirty eight years in compliance of AT and T. I recently retired, from that position. And in that position, I had eighteen years of true corporate compliance where I worked with many different organizations from our security office, privacy office, supply chain, many different areas where we, work together to address issues and questions that might come up in regards to our vendors. Yeah. Thank you so much for being with us. We've already had conversations in the past. I hope many conversations will follow in the future. A true expert indeed, Reginald. Thank you so much for being with us. My name is Jan Stopperts. I'm a lawyer from The Netherlands, and I'm the EVP of solutions strategy here at Mitratech. Why did we decide to discuss this particular topic? Because amongst our 8,000 plus customers, it's a topic that remains a challenge or at least a topic of interest for many of our accounts. So that's why we'll be looking into, these aspects today. Please make sure that we hear from you. This is a live webinar. Everything can go wrong, but I don't think it will. But we we are... We live. We can track your questions and live answer them. There is not just time for q and a at the end of the session, but we can see your questions coming in any moment. So please don't hesitate. Don't wait for the actual end of this webinar. And if you need to jump off or you are not able to see this webinar live, this webinar is recorded and will be available on demand. And to warm you up, at least where I am, it's pretty chilly. We want to start with a poll. A poll question, and we're very much looking forward to knowing your answers. Imagine there's a situation where a colleague asks you which vendor could harm your organization. How confident are you, to be able to actually answer that question? Reginald, is this a... While we wait for the votes to come in, Reginald, is this a purely theoretic, question, or are those questions actually being asked? What's your what's your experience? I can guarantee you those questions are being asked. In today's world with as many things going on every day, every night, there's a different issue or or something that comes up where an executive is asking questions about what's the environment, where are we, what are we doing. It is a constant day. I would wake up in the morning wondering what's waiting on me when I walk through the door. So this is very real. And I think even since I've retired in six months ago, I think it's become even more prevalent just because of the amount of activities that are going on, involving third party, fourth party vendors. Yeah. Thank you. And we see actually from the results, all the people who voted, they said, well, we are somewhat confident. No one there to say I'm super confident, on answering that question. So I think there's room for improvement amongst everyone who vaulted, who joined the poll. Thank you for that. If we look at today's agenda, we'll be looking at the gap. We'll be we'll be looking specifically at what it means, to assess third parties, and still not being... Not have full visibility on what the landscape actually looks like to make sure how an answer is actually reliable. One of the vendors answers... Or all the all the answers from the, vendors are actually reliable. And then we want to finalize the webinar with actual best practices. What could you do to improve your program tomorrow? First question, Reginald. And this is a question that was distilled based on a lot of topics, in this area that was... A lot of topics that were raised amongst our audience. When you ask your team which vendors could harm the organization now, it is very similar to the poll question. Which answer do you actually receive, and what answer do you wish you received? What does reality look like in this regard? What what would people typically answer, and how is it different from the answers that you wished for? Sure. And that's a great way to phrase that question. The the key thing when you're asked that question in in assessing, do you have all the right information on... To assess the vendor? A key part of it is assessing how old is the data that you have. Where did you get that data from? Can you trust that information? Because you start making decisions based off of the information that you might have. You need to know where it came from and if it has changed. Because today's environment where it could have been a low risk vendor then and now is a high risk vendor because of how, the environment has changed. And I know one of the things from my experience, the questions we asked greatly depended on the risk of the vendor. Therefore, the answers I might have might only give me part of the solution and not all the solution of what I'm looking for. So when I look at the information I have, it really is taking a step back and assessing, does it answer all the key questions that's relevant today? There's a comment from the audience, and please keep those coming. Reginald, what do you think of the following, scenarios? Some vendors may not have advised you of all their third party vendors that they're using, and that continues to their vendors, to their vendors, etcetera, etcetera. Where do you draw the line? How do you mitigate this risk? What we've had... What my experience with that... And and that is so true. First thing is to realize that, is to take that consideration that you're not getting the complete view. The way I would address it, what I've addressed in the past, is by assessing which of the vendors would put you on... Put you on the front page the fastest, which one has the highest risk. Then from those vendors, concentrate on and asking them and letting them know the importance that if they're if they're using fourth party vendors, if they're using other subcontractors, if they're changing, let you know and have you do an assessment to determine which of those subvendors are more critical. So, therefore, what I'm saying is take that information, assess where you are, assess which vendors could put you in the most risk, and then start to dive down deeper and ask those specific questions. And let... One of the big things is to communicate with your vendors to let them know, my expectation is that if you're using a sub vendor, let me know. Therefore, I can ask additional questions, and I could assess how deep do I need to go because you can't assess every situation to the same level. So, therefore, it depends on the risk that you find with your vendors. Hopefully, that answers it. Yeah. I'm afraid, indeed, there is no one size fits all in this regard. It It really depends, on the particular situation. If we move on to the second question that we prepared, a vendor can be fully assessed and is still not visible. How how have you seen that gap appearing in practice? Sure. With that, you can do that assessment, but that's only the beginning. And what you have to do is take it to the next step. And in practice, again, have a relationship with those vendors. Let them know your expectations. One of the biggest things I've seen is having accountability. Who's responsible for communicating with that vendor? Who's responsible for gathering that information? And if the vendor has an issue, who do they call? Therefore, you gather all that information, then you can determine your next steps. Who do you communicate with? How do you fix, address any issues you might find? How how would you... Because that question often comes up, what is a full assessment? Because like like we we learned in the previous question, one size doesn't fit all. It fits few, maybe even in some sectors. How do you make sure that a vendor is considered fully assessed? What is that actually? I would say, again, one size doesn't fit all, but let's just take, for example, your highest risk vendor. What you have to do or what I would do is if that is a true risk, you look at what kind of risk it's providing to you. What are they doing that causes you to stay up at night? From there, that's when you can go to third... Other third party vendors where you can gather data. They specialize in gathering data about other vendors. And I would also set up meetings with them so to better understand what questions you need to ask. Because the data could say one thing, but reality could be something different. The main thing is communication and then having continuous monitoring where you're talking and engaging with them. Let's move on to question, three. What would make a vendor risk answer reliable enough for you to act on it? I would look at the, of course, the... Not only how thorough it looks to be, but also looking at how was it gathered, looking at when was it gathered, and looking at how does it compare with other information you might have received from other resources. If those things start to check out, then I'm more comfortable with the answer. But if you are seeing all... We're doing all the above, but then when you talk and look and gather other information, it seems like you're not getting the full picture, that's when I would dive deeper. Therefore, it's back to really assessing that real life communication with them to see if the data you have in hand makes sense. You can't just look at it from one source. That's why it's important to talk to other partners, organizations that you might have to see if they're getting the same answer. If we look at the topic of... I mean, now, we've been looking at question answer or assessment output, or input from those vendors. But in time, I'm actually a big fan of life insights. So something changes somewhere in your network, in the supply chain or vendor, whatever you want to call it. Things change all the time. It's become such a... It became such a dynamic environment. Right. Still a lot of organizations have periodic reviews. Some of them call it periodic, but, actually, it's been there for years already without a new review. That might be feasible for some vendors, but if you start digging deeper, their third parties are very likely to have changed. So what is your recommendation? What is your experience also regarding revisiting these assessments to make sure that they're still actual and relevant? That goes back to the... I can't emphasize how important it is to really have an inventory of all of the vendors that you have, third and fourth party. Then once you do that inventory, that assessment goes... Plays such an important role. And that's where the assessment... Like, for example, if you know that vendor is working with you with AI, then you're gonna ask specific AI related questions to really determine, are you getting comfortable? If the answers matches your governance program, matches your framework, then you're in good position. But if you start seeing answers that, again, will not match, might not match, and it's against your own culture, your own governance, your own framework, that's when the red flag goes up, and that's when you get with the vendor relationship manager and say, hey. I'm not comfortable with what I'm seeing and what I'm hearing from this vendor. Can you dive depth... Can you dive deeper into this? And maybe get on a phone call with that vendor and let them know you've got concerns. I I see so many times where people are hesitant to engage with that vendor. They're just looking at the data and not engaging directly with the vendor live and asking questions. You... Of course, you you speak... I I believe your experience is mostly AT and T. It's a giant organization. But in our audience, and definitely within our customers, there are a lot of organizations that are actually quite hesitant, as you say, to ask those questions because there's such a size mismatch. They're using the the giant tech companies of, the the... Of nowadays. They're they're actually very happy to work with a certain vendor, and they brag about having that particular vendor as a vendor. What would be your advice to these kind of organizations, especially when they receive pushback on... Well, we've been through this exercise already last year. And to be honest, you're not the only one asking me to, submit, all my answers. You're number 327 this month because I have so many other parties I'm working with. Yes. What what would be your recommendation to organizations who are maybe small, medium sized enterprises to still get the insights that they really need? What I would do with that, I've run into that even though I have spent, as as mentioned, my many years with AT and T, but I have talked to others and I've, interfaced with them. In those situations, I make sure that my upper management is aware that I can only gather this type of information from this vendor. And if I only have this information, there's a certain amount of risk of what I might not know and what I do know and what I feel comfortable with. So let's step... Take a step back. One, update upper management. Therefore, everybody's on the same path of what you can... What you what you have and what you do not have. Two is still to engage and try to partner with that vendor, to let them know, I know I'm I'm not as large. I know I've got, I don't have as many resources maybe to help solve some of these questions and answers, but I still say engagement and documentation. Document that you did reach out to them, that you did try to engage with them to answer questions, to address risk. I can't say how important that is because if you get the knock on the door that something happens with that vendor, one of the first questions it's gonna ask was, did you know they had this issue? If you did, what did you do to try to mitigate the risk associated with that issue? If you can't mitigate that a conversation happened, but you had... You were aware and you just say, I was trying, they didn't answer my phone call. I think the better answer is, here's the document. This is when I called. This is where I escalated. So everybody's on the same page in case that not happened. Yeah. That's really good. Always keep thinking of that audit trail, please. Last question. We still have thirteen minutes left, so we can really elaborate on this one and, of course, love to hear from the audience if there are additional questions. A third party risk manager returns to the desk tomorrow morning. And assuming that there are third party risk managers in the audience, what would be the first takeaway, according to you regarding the data that they already have at their disposal? What more can people do with data that's typically, like we say in Dutch, under their nose? I think a key component of that is when returning is assessing what are the risk... What's the risk look like today? What's our environment look like? Then I compare the data that I have, the age of the data, the type of questions that were asked, the answers, anything that could raise red flags, and then assess where do I go from there. Some of the vendors cost you might have a smaller size company, and you might not have the ability to go check every vendor. But again, I will start with the ones that when you left, were the highest risk. Were there any changes? Talking to the vendor relationship manager. Gathering that information and then determining your next step. Therefore, basically, doing an assessment on your own information that you have to see where you need to start from. Is there any... And and meanwhile, I'll put up the next slide so that people can, register for further engagement. But while we leave that slide up, is there any best practice, guidance, standards out there that you found particularly handy in achieving those goals? Yes. I... The the best practice I I always live by, one, is to develop, your your group of trust And that I'm a person that people who know me, I believe in the making deposits, meaning talking, communicating with people around you, key organizations, ahead of when the phone call happens where something hits the fan. That's number one, develop your group of support. Two, look at the framework that you have. Does that framework encompass all the different things that could happen? Communication between groups, escalations. How are you gathering when something goes wrong? Who... Do they know who to communicate with? So two is back to a a break framework. Three goes into having an escalation path documented. Your processes documented. A lot of people forget about that. And I'm... I'll just quickly mention here kind of old school. While we talk about some of the new things that are going on, the new risks like AI, people, please don't forget about the old risk, record retention. Don't forget about social engineering. Those things that have been there that we've worried about as third party risk management compliance practitioners, those things are still there. AI is added to it. Again, when you're doing your assessment, do a full assessment looking at the risk, looking at the environment, and looking at any new laws that might have come on board since the last time you did that assessment. If we look at the board reporting, this is another topic that comes up a lot during conversations with our customers. We see the shifting role from compliance manager in a broad sense of the word, basically anyone working in GRC, being much more included in the strategy of the organization, having a much more of a advisory role within organizations. How do you see the third party risk management function from that... In in in... From that perspective? From a... Make sure I understand. From a board perspective? So from a perspective where there's more, of a request, and actually expectation also to think along proactively and think strategically. So beyond, okay. I did the assessment. You can sign off towards, you know, maybe there are better vendors to work with. Maybe there are risks that are... We can manage the risk, but I still want to flag it, take into account where we're going as an organization, etcetera, etcetera. How have you seen that role developing in that regard? I I... It's it's interesting to watch, and I think it's because the environment that we're in. Is... For example, to direct answer your question, I get a report every morning that says what happened the night before, what kind of issues popped up. Board members are getting the same type of reports, and they are being asked and thinking about... For this company that I'm on a board for, whether they're doing in these areas. I think in the past, you can... The questions and the the... And the answers provided were not as detailed as what you're getting today. They wanna know specifically where are our risks, what kind of tools that we have, where are we missing, what things are keeping you up at night. I think the be real with the board, and I think the board is being more real with the companies and saying, I need to know the details. I do not like surprises. Therefore, I think what we're seeing is kind of a shift. Now they might not understand all the answers, but at least I think they're... The boards are starting to have that expectation that when you give me an answer, it's the full answer. It tells me what I have and what I do not have, and then where are we going from here. That's the last thing I should mention too is make sure you have... If you have issues, have a road map to address those issues. Don't just lay them out there. Say this is how I'm trying to address it and make sure everybody knows about it. That goes part of your enterprise risk management program. I think the last question or maybe before last question, depending also on questions coming in, of course, the... Again, in the broader sense, the GRC functions are increasingly asked to prove the value they added to the organization. Is that a conversation you've had in in your career? So going beyond, well, we need to have somebody doing third party risk management towards, wow, this person actually brought the following value to our organization. How how how do you reflect on that angle? It's it's a great question. From our perspective, a number of things come to mind. The value add is always hard to capture, especially when you're trying to protect from doing something that could cause you issues. But what we try to capture was more of the change in culture, change in mindset. So for example, a part of the team that I was on had a third party risk management week. You know, you've got other types of groups that have privacy week, other compliance week. But this was just a week to change the culture, change the knowledge. We... I mentioned that from a value perspective because what ended up happening, people started to knock on the door and said, hey. I wanna be part of your team. Hey. I want to better understand how we are addressing this. Oh, did you know that this was going on? I never thought to add your team to it. Therefore, the value of it sometimes comes from a standpoint of just people working together towards a common direction compared to people working independently and not understanding the risk. That enabled us to capture a value from a perspective of we could show how we save money. We could show where risks were reduced, mitigated because of the value of a third party risk management program. And the tools, because we also started to share tools with other groups like supply chain and other groups that would, enable us to be more proactive towards issues. Yeah. Thank you very much. Is there anything else that we should cover? I mean, this is only a thirty minute sharp webinar. We believe that a lot of people who've been watching this webinar and who will be watching this webinar have significant experience in the third party risk management field. Main takeaway from your perspective? I mean, you're you're seasoned in this regard and in a much broader sense, of course, taking to account all the, experience that you have during your career. What what will be apart from make sure that you always remember your audit trail, your accountability, what else would you really like to pass on to the next generation of people who are now still working, who didn't retire yet, who are active in the third party risk management space? would say take the time to develop partnerships, and not just by word partnerships, but true partners where you go out to lunch. True partners that if you call at 2AM in the morning, they will pick up the phone. I believe in doing that when the phone isn't red. You know, when it's not a problem, I'd rather develop that conversation ahead of time. Second key thing is also understanding the other push points, the other pain points of other groups. I can't say how many times where I've said in meetings and acronyms started to flow and people didn't understand what was going on. In my career, I noticed... I started invited... Get invited to more meetings when I spent the time to either get a certification that was relevant to our privacy or our CSO organization. I know everybody's busy, busy, busy, but the more they see that you are investing to understand their pressures, their issues, the direction they're trying to go in, that you can talk their language, the more likely they're gonna give you the funding, the more likely they're going to want you to be at that table and want your input. So therefore, my main message is invest early. It will pay off later. Thank you so much. I have nothing to add to this. This is re... I I always love to speak with people who actually have the experience. Reginald, I very much look forward to our following conversation because I'm pretty sure, various will follow. Dear audience, thank you so much for being with us, for asking your questions, and please don't hesitate to, ask any questions or, just connect with us after this webinar. We'd love to hear from you. Thanks again for your time, everyone. Thanks for being on the webinar, and looking forward to the next webinar to welcome you there. Thank you. Have a nice for your work. your day. Bye bye. Bye bye.